How Options Move Stock and Index Prices: A Plain Guide
· 9 min read
Behind every option sits a market maker who hedges with stocks and futures. See how that hedging can calm prices down or speed them up.

Ever noticed the S&P 500 hovering around a round number late in the session? Or a small dip suddenly turning into a sharp drop? Sometimes the options market is part of the story. In this guide you'll see, in plain English, how options trades turn into real buying and selling of stocks and futures, when that calms prices down and when it speeds them up.
Options, market makers and delta
An option works a bit like a deposit: you pay a small amount for the right to buy (call) or sell (put) something at a set price before a set date. That set price is called the strike.
When you buy or sell an option, the trader on the other side is often a market maker. Think of the owner of a secondhand bookshop: they buy from people clearing their shelves and sell to readers, and they earn from the gap between the two prices. Guessing whether books will get more popular next year isn't their game.
Market makers are the same. They don't want to bet on the direction of the market, so they offset the risk of their options by taking positions in the stock itself or in index futures. This is called hedging. A US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) document describes exactly this practice. Here's the key idea of this article: hedging is the bridge between the options market and stock prices.
Delta: how many shares does one option act like?
Delta tells you roughly how much an option's price moves for every $1 move in the stock. An example from a filing published by the SEC: an option with a delta of 0.5 moves about 50 cents for each $1 move in the stock.
An easier way to see it: delta tells you how many shares an option behaves like. A standard US stock option contract typically covers 100 shares, so one call contract with a delta of 0.5 behaves roughly like 50 shares.
- A call that is deep in profit has a delta close to 1.
- A call with a strike far above the current price has a delta close to 0.
- A put has a negative delta, because it gains when the stock falls.
The market maker adds up how many shares all their options act like and takes the opposite position in stock, so the total comes to zero. This is called being delta neutral. Picture a cyclist making tiny steering corrections to stay upright.
Gamma: why the hedging never stops
Here's the catch: delta doesn't stay still. As the stock moves, delta changes too. The speed of that change is called gamma. Cboe, the exchange where all S&P 500 index (SPX) options trade, describes gamma as how much market makers have to adjust their hedge after the index moves.
That gives two situations:
- Long gamma: market makers have, overall, bought options. They sell as the market rises and buy as it falls. They trade against the move and act like a car's shock absorbers.
- Short gamma: market makers have, overall, sold options. Now they have to buy more as the market rises and sell more as it falls. They trade with the move and act like an accelerator pedal.
A simple worked example (hypothetical)
Say Stock A trades at $100. Some traders buy 10 call contracts on it from a market maker. Each contract covers 100 shares and each call has a delta of 0.5.
- The market maker sold calls, so it's as if they were short 10 × 100 × 0.5 = 500 shares. To neutralise that, they buy 500 shares.
- Stock A rises to $105 and delta moves to 0.7. Now the options act like 700 shares. The market maker holds 500, so they buy 200 more: in a rising market, they become a buyer too.
- If instead the stock drops to $95 and delta falls to 0.3, the options act like only 300 shares. The market maker sells 200: in a falling market, they become a seller too.
That's short gamma. Now flip it: if the traders had sold those 10 calls to the market maker, the market maker would sell 200 shares at $105 and buy 200 at $95, leaning against the move. These numbers only show the logic. In real markets, delta also depends on time left and volatility.
Expiry day, pinning and zero-day options
Near expiration, gamma gets stronger and hedges change faster. A well-known paper in the journal Quantitative Finance (by a New York University researcher and a trader at the American Stock Exchange) argued that when open interest (the number of contracts still open) at one strike is unusually large and market makers own those options, their hedging can pull the stock towards that strike in the final minutes. This is called pinning. Think of a magnet pulling in a paper clip.
But note: the same paper says pinning only happens with some probability, not every time, and you can't know in advance which stock will pin. One big headline can switch the magnet off.
Zero-day options (0DTE)
A big share of S&P 500 index options trading now happens in contracts that expire the same day. According to Cboe, these went from about 5% of SPX options volume in 2016 to about 50% in August 2023, and topped 61% in May 2025. That month, retail traders made up about 54% of this 0DTE volume.
Many people worried that hedging all this volume would shake the market. Cboe's own data pointed the other way: high volume doesn't mean high risk. What matters is the balance between customers buying and selling. If half buy and half sell, the market maker has almost nothing to hedge. In Cboe's study, the hedging needed for 0DTE options was on average only around 0.04% to 0.17% of daily S&P futures liquidity.
How it connects to other markets
- Options → futures → CFDs: when Cboe estimates how much market makers need to hedge, it expresses it as buying or selling S&P futures. An index CFD is built on the price of that same index, so pressure that reaches the futures and the index also shows up on your CFD chart.
- Options → VIX: the VIX volatility index is based on one-month S&P 500 options. The Bank for International Settlements (BIS) noted that for most of 2023 the VIX stayed below its long-term average of around 20, despite plenty of uncertainty. One explanation it offered: banks acting as dealers had in effect bought options from clients through yield-enhancing structured products (for example, holding the index while selling a call on it). Hedging those positions meant buying dips and selling rallies, which can dampen swings.
- A real-world example: on 15 August 2023, between 3pm and 3:30pm New York time (8pm to 8:30pm in London), the S&P 500 fell about 0.4%, from 4451 to 4433. Many blamed a zero-day 4440 put that traded more than 100,000 contracts. But Cboe's data showed market makers were long about $2 billion of gamma at 3pm, so their hedging should have softened the drop, not caused it.
The lesson: options do affect prices, but not all the time and not always in the same direction. These links aren't fixed. They shift as market maker positioning, volume and the news change.
Common mistakes
- Assuming big options volume means a big price move. Balance matters more than volume.
- Treating a crowded strike as a sure buy or sell signal. Pinning is only a possibility.
- Taking "gamma exposure" figures from websites at face value. Cboe has pointed out that outside estimates are often contradictory, because only the exchange sees the full detail of who bought and who sold.
- Chasing zero-day options because they look cheap. The BIS found that buying them lost money on average, even though they occasionally paid off hugely.
Practical checklist
- Before the trading week starts, check the expiry dates for index options.
- Mark big round-number strikes near the current price on your chart, and treat them as extra context next to your support and resistance, not a replacement.
- Notice whether the market has been calm or jumpy lately, and size your trades to match.
- If you trade an S&P 500 CFD from the UK, be extra alert in the last hours of the US session on expiry days, which fall in your evening.
- Never take a trade on options data alone. Combine it with market structure and risk management.
Frequently asked questions
Can options change the direction of the market?
Their hedging mostly affects the speed and smoothness of a move rather than its main direction. Cboe's data suggests that for zero-day options, even that effect has usually been small.
How can I tell if market makers are long or short gamma?
Only the exchange knows for sure, because it sees whether each trade was a buy or a sell. Outside tools can only estimate, so treat their numbers as a guide, not a verdict.
Does this matter if I only trade CFDs?
If you trade an S&P 500 CFD, yes. The effect of options hedging reaches the futures and the index, and from there your CFD price.
Does pinning mean the price will definitely close at the strike?
No. Research only says the chance goes up in certain conditions. One headline or one large order can change everything.
Wrapping up
Options aren't a separate island. Behind every contract sits a market maker who has to buy or sell stock or futures to stay balanced. When market makers are long gamma, the market may calm down; when they're short gamma, moves may speed up. Near expiry, crowded strikes sometimes act like magnets. None of this is a hard rule.
Want a stronger foundation? Try our free courses, and to look at market data up close, check out our software.
Adapted from: Cboe (1, 2), Bank for International Settlements (BIS), US SEC, US Federal Register and New York University (NYU)
Trading involves a significant risk of loss. This article is for educational purposes only and is not financial advice.
